Blog / Robotic Knee Replacement: Benefits, Risks and Who Should Consider It

Robotic Knee Replacement: Benefits, Risks and Who Should Consider It

Robot-Assisted Knee Replacement: Benefits, Risks, and Who It’s Right For

Knee pain can become so severe that it prevents you from taking care of yourself and doing everyday activities. Walking, climbing stairs, or standing for long periods can become painful. For some patients, the solution is knee replacement, an advanced procedure for knee osteoarthritis or severe joint damage that offers the chance for improved mobility and reduced pain.

Innovations in surgical technology have also led to robot-assisted procedures, such as the MAKO robotic knee replacement system. Patients should understand how robotic knee replacement works, who it is suitable for, and when MAKO technology is worth considering, so they can make an informed decision.

What You Need to Know About Robotic Knee Replacement

Robotic knee replacement is a procedure performed by an orthopedic surgeon who uses robot-assisted technology to plan and perform the joint replacement. The system provides precise details about the patient’s anatomy, which help the surgeon position the components of the artificial joint.

The robot does not operate on its own. The surgeon is in constant control of the procedure and uses the technology to assist with planning and surgical guidance.

MAKO is a robot-assisted surgical system used in certain joint replacement procedures. It can be used for both total and partial knee replacement, depending on the patient’s condition and the chosen procedure.

The MAKO Procedure: What to Expect

The MAKO procedure typically begins with a CT scan of the knee, which is used to create a three-dimensional model of the patient’s anatomy. The surgeon then uses this model to develop a personalized surgical plan.

The surgeon performs the surgery, and the robotic arm assists in preparing the bone for the implant. The system can help the surgeon work within predefined limits and evaluate various aspects of joint alignment and soft tissue balance.

According to medical literature, the MAKO procedure allows for customized planning, meaning it enables planning tailored to each patient, rather than relying exclusively on standard measurements. The exact workflow and available functions, however, depend on the procedure, the system version, and the surgeon’s decision.

Possible Benefits of the MAKO Procedure

There are several reasons why the MAKO procedure may be considered. When used on suitable patients, MAKO technology can offer a number of benefits:

  • 3D imaging allows the surgeon to plan the procedure based on the individual anatomy of the knee.
  • The robotic arm helps the surgeon adhere to predefined surgical boundaries during bone preparation.
  • The technology enables precise positioning of the implant according to the surgical plan.
  • The system helps the surgeon, in appropriate procedures, assess the knee’s range of motion and soft tissue balance.
  • Some patients may experience improvement in both pain and function after surgery.

When to Consider the Mako Procedure

If knee pain significantly affects your daily life and nonsurgical treatments no longer provide sufficient relief, it’s worth discussing the Mako procedure with an orthopedic surgeon. Typical situations are described below.

Moderate or severe knee osteoarthritis

Osteoarthritis gradually wears down the cartilage that cushions the knee joint, causing pain, stiffness, swelling, and loss of mobility. If imaging shows significant joint damage and your symptoms are affecting your daily comfort, your surgeon may discuss with you whether a total or partial knee replacement is necessary.

Medication and physical therapy are no longer effective

Treatment for knee osteoarthritis may include exercise-based physical therapy, weight management, pain medication, and supportive devices. When these methods no longer provide sufficient relief, surgery may become an option, and if the surgeon recommends a knee replacement, MAKO may be one of the techniques considered.

A surgical plan tailored to you

The MAKO system utilizes a 3D model from your CT scans, meaning it uses a three-dimensional model built from your CT images to help plan the size, position, and alignment of the implant. Talk to your surgeon about robot-assisted surgery as an option alongside conventional knee replacement.

You are a candidate for partial knee replacement

Partial knee replacement may be an option when osteoarthritis is limited to one side of the knee and the rest of the joint is still in good condition; some partial procedures can be performed using Mako technology. Not all patients need a partial knee replacement; the decision depends on the condition of the ligaments, the stability of the knee, and the overall health of the joint.

How to Evaluate a New Surgical Technology

The question patients typically ask during a consultation—whether the robot is better than the surgeon’s hand—implies that the answer already exists, in a form that the doctor simply needs to convey. The medical literature, however, addresses the issue in different terms. In 2009, Peter McCulloch and a group of surgeons and methodologists gathered under the Balliol Collaboration published the IDEAL recommendations in The Lancet under the title “No surgical innovation without evaluation.”

The framework describes five stages through which a surgical innovation passes: idea, development, exploration in larger patient groups, rigorous comparative assessment, and long-term follow-up. The authors noted that surgical procedures, unlike medications, depend on the surgeon, the team, and the learning curve, which is why traditional studies are difficult to apply, and prospective registries become indispensable. Their central recommendation was that each stage should generate the appropriate evidence before the technique is adopted into routine practice.

When applied to robotic knee replacement, this framework reveals an asymmetry worth noting. Adoption has proceeded much faster than evaluation. According to the Australian Orthopedic Arthroplasty Registry (AOANJRR), cited in a study published in 2026 in JBJS Open Access by Hoskins and colleagues, 41.9% of total knee replacements performed in Australia in 2024 were recorded as robot-assisted.
The same authors note that this widespread adoption was likely driven by manufacturers and the pressure surgeons feel to adopt the technology. In the United States, an analysis of the American Arthroplasty Registry, published in *Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research*, found no association between robotic assistance and a lower risk of revision within the first two years.

The IDEAL framework has its limitations, and they are not negligible. It is prescriptive—that is, it describes how an innovation should be evaluated—without guaranteeing that manufacturers, hospitals, or authorities will follow it. The stages often overlap in practice, and an individual patient cannot deduce from a technology’s stage what the outcome of their own surgery will be. The lack of a statistical advantage at the follow-up visit also does not prove that the robot is not helpful: the follow-up measures serious failures, not patient satisfaction, residual pain, or function, and observational studies compare surgeons and hospitals that differ from one another in many other respects.

What the Australian registry shows—and what it cannot show

The Australian Orthopaedic Association National Joint Replacement Registry collects data on nearly all joint replacements in Australia, from both public and private hospitals. The registry publishes annual reports on the performance of each type of prosthesis, including lists of implants with revision rates higher than expected. For patients, this is likely the most useful public verification tool, as it allows for a specific question: What implant am I about to receive, and what does the registry show about it?

However, the registry has a limitation that patients only discover when they search: the data is published by prosthesis type and procedure category, not by individual surgeons. The revision rate for a specific orthopedic surgeon is not found in a public report, and the information can only be obtained by asking the doctor directly, who can receive reports on their own activity from the registry. This leads to a simple rule for consultation: the robot, the implant, and the surgeon are three distinct variables, and a sound decision requires all three.

The first of these variables is less uniform than the word “robotic” suggests. The systems in use today differ from one another in how they collect data about the knee. Mako, developed by Stryker, starts with a CT scan and uses haptic limits that stop the instrument outside the planned area, while other platforms use X-rays or build the model directly in the operating room, without preoperative imaging. A practical consequence, rarely explained to patients, is that the Mako system is used with implants from the same manufacturer, so choosing the robot also implies choosing a specific family of prostheses. This fact is not in itself a disadvantage, since the implants in question have a long history in registries, but it illustrates why the question of the implant cannot be separated from that of the technology, and why results published for one system do not automatically apply to another.

Useful Questions for the Surgeon

Based on the above, the consultation can be structured around a few specific questions. The patient can ask how many knee replacements the surgeon performs per year and how many years the surgeon has been using the robotic system. Next come questions about the proposed implant, its standing in registry reports, what would specifically change in the surgical plan if the procedure were performed conventionally, and the additional costs that the patient must bear after health insurance reimbursement.

Questions like these transform a choice between “robot” and “no robot”—usually framed in advertising terms—into a discussion about outcomes, experience, and costs, that is, about the things the patient will actually experience after surgery.

The Learning Curve and What It Means for the Patient

One of the observations that the IDEAL framework has brought to the forefront concerns the learning curve—that is, the period during which a surgeon, even an experienced one, adapts their movements, operating times, and coordination with the team to a new technique. In the case of robotic systems, this effect has been explicitly studied. A study published in 2019 in the *Bone & Joint Journal* by Kayani and colleagues was conducted at a single London center. The authors reported that operative time stabilized after approximately seven procedures, with no learning effect on the precision with which the implant was positioned.

The result is reassuring in terms of mechanical precision, but it should be interpreted with caution, as it comes from a small number of highly experienced surgeons at a research center, and its generalizability to any hospital is uncertain. For the patient, the practical implication is that the question of the surgeon’s experience with the robotic system remains legitimate, and a precise answer—expressed in terms of the number of procedures and years of use—speaks louder than a general assurance that the technology is safe.

Expectations: The Variable the Robot Cannot Control

The conclusion of this text rightly addresses the need to weigh expectations, and the orthopedic literature provides measurable data to support this idea. In a Canadian study published in 2010 in *Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research*, Robert Bourne and colleagues followed more than 1,000 patients who underwent total knee replacement and found that approximately one in five was dissatisfied with the outcome one year after surgery.
The strongest factor associated with dissatisfaction was unmet expectations, rather than complications or the technical characteristics of the surgery.

The study was conducted before the widespread adoption of robotic systems and says nothing directly about them. Its relevance lies elsewhere. The precision with which an implant is positioned is a necessary condition for a good outcome, but patient satisfaction also depends on residual pain, recovery, and how well the patient was informed before surgery about what they can and cannot expect. An honest discussion about these matters is probably at least as important as the choice of technology.

Checking the Surgeon and the Clinic

Before the consultation, there are a few checks that can be made without any medical knowledge. The public registry of the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency (AHPR) shows whether a doctor has a valid registration and whether they are registered as a specialist in orthopedic surgery, as well as any conditions imposed on their right to practice. Medical devices sold in Australia must be listed in the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods, administered by the Therapeutic Goods Administration.

The real challenge, however, arises one step earlier—at the stage when the patient does not yet know which clinics in their area offer the procedure or who performs it. Online searches are dominated by paid advertisements, and the term “robotic” has become, in many of them, a marketing pitch rather than clinical information. To identify clinics and providers, curated directories offer a different starting point. The medical procedures and therapies category in the Jasmine Directory brings together organizations that treat or manage a medical condition, ranging from minor outpatient procedures to major surgery, and each listing undergoes an editorial review. Such a listing confirms the clinic’s existence, its stated specialty, and its contact information. It does not confirm the physician’s qualifications, does not measure surgical outcomes, and does not constitute a recommendation; verification in the AHPAA registry remains mandatory.

The same logic applies to technology. Patients who want to understand who manufactures, distributes, and maintains the equipment used in the operating room can consult the category medical equipment and supplies, whose editorial description also covers orthopedic implants and the regulatory framework for medical devices. This information serves as context, as the decision regarding the implant and surgical method rests with the surgeon and the patient together.

Recovery After Robotic Knee Replacement

Postoperative recovery varies from person to person. The type of surgery, overall health, and how the body heals determine the pace of recovery, and patients typically work with the medical team to manage pain.

Robotic assistance does not replace medical recovery and does not guarantee a faster recovery. Follow postoperative instructions, attend scheduled follow-up appointments, and report any unusual symptoms that arise during recovery immediately.

Conclusion

The MAKO robotic system offers surgeons a technology-assisted approach to personalized surgical planning and bone preparation. It may be an option for patients with severe knee osteoarthritis, but the best treatment is one that takes your condition into account while weighing the potential benefits, risks, and expectations.

This article was written on:

Atila-Robert Gomboș
Atila-Robert Gomboș
is the co-founder and CEO of Jasmine Directory (since 2009), where he handles the editorial review of submissions. From 2011 to 2017 he was a volunteer editor of DMOZ (Open Directory Project). Since May 2024 he has also been IT Manager, IT Procurement Specialist and CISO at Printopia S.R.L., Timișoara. He earned a BA, a Master's degree and a doctorate in Visual Arts (2024, Magna Cum Laude) from the West University of Timișoara, and a Bachelor's degree from Babeș-Bolyai University Cluj-Napoca. He is the editor of the online journal "Artă și Artiști Vizuali" (ISSN 2734-6196). Doctoral thesis: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.20514341; ORCID iD: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6468-2811.
LIST YOUR WEBSITE
POPULAR

Dealing with web directories

Web directories today range from general ones that cover a broad spectrum of topics to niche directories focused on specific industries or interests. They are useful for businesses that want visibility, users looking for reliable information, and webmasters building...

Women-Focused African Directory Platforms Rise

Women-focused African directory platforms are changing how female entrepreneurs and professionals connect across the continent. These platforms address specific problems women face in business, from limited networking to weak visibility in ordinary business directories. Looking at how they are...

Best AI Recruiting Software Platforms: Why Greenhouse Is Built for Structured Hiring

Key TakeawaysGreenhouse is designed for organizations that want AI assistance within a structured, accountable hiring process. Its value is not limited to automation. The platform connects interview planning, scorecards, candidate workflows, reporting, and AI-enabled recruiting tasks. Teams should...