The credentials at Daugherty Plastic Surgery are in order, the procedure list is long, and a rating gap between platforms is unexplained enough to give any careful patient pause.

The reputation question

Birdeye shows 222 reviews at 4.9 stars for what is currently listed under the former Weiler Plastic Surgery name. Healthgrades credits Dr. Robyn Daugherty with over 15 years of experience and a likelihood-to-recommend score of 3.3 out of 5 from a small patient count. US News rates the practice across six categories from five reviews, a number too low to draw conclusions from. BBB accreditation and an A+ rating are on record.

A 4.9 on 222 reviews versus a 3.3 on Healthgrades is not statistical noise. These platforms draw different reviewer pools, and the Healthgrades number may catch patients who did not bother with Birdeye. Neither platform's written reviews can be assessed from a directory listing, which is precisely the problem: the practice's own channels will always favor favorable cases, and 222 near-perfect scores on a single aggregator for a solo-surgeon office warrants a closer look at who left them and when. The Birdeye profile still carries the Weiler name, and whether that reflects a simple rebrand or a change in clinical staff is worth clarifying before drawing any comfort from that review count.

What Daugherty Plastic Surgery covers

The procedure range is genuinely wide. Breast work includes augmentation, lift, reduction, fat transfer augmentation, revision, and gynecomastia. Revision cases are technically demanding and many practices sidestep them; their presence here says something about clinical scope, whatever one thinks of the rating picture. Body procedures run to tummy tuck, liposuction, mommy makeover, labiaplasty, body lift, arm lift, thigh lift, and post-weight-loss contouring. Facial work covers facelift, neck lift, rhinoplasty, brow lift, eyelid surgery, chin augmentation, buccal fat removal, facial fat grafting, and lip augmentation. Non-surgical options include Botox, dermal fillers, VI Peel, and SkinPen microneedling.

Dr. Daugherty holds double board certification in plastic surgery. Daugherty Plastic Surgery publishes pricing, financing details, a before-and-after gallery, gift cards, and a skincare shop. A procedure blog is available. Social presence spans Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, TikTok, and RealSelf, so patient results are visible outside the practice's own curated pages.

Contact and geography

A phone number and a Perkins Road, Baton Rouge address appear on the Daugherty Plastic Surgery website. A contact page and a reviews page are linked in navigation. The stated service area includes Baton Rouge, Lafayette, and the Northshore communities of Covington, Mandeville, and Madisonville.

Where the evidence lands

Double board certification, transparent pricing, published before-and-after photos across multiple channels, more than 15 years of experience on record, and a procedure list that includes revision work: these are not nothing. But the 3.3 on Healthgrades is low enough that it cannot be set aside just because a different platform reads 4.9. A prospective patient planning a significant procedure should read the actual written reviews on both Birdeye and Healthgrades, not the star averages, and ask the practice directly whether the Weiler Plastic Surgery name on Birdeye reflects a name change only or a change in clinical staff. That answer will matter more than anything on Daugherty Plastic Surgery's own website.

---