Thirty years, two partners, two offices

Kimmey & Murphy, P.C. has been in continuous operation in Atlanta, Georgia for over 30 years, built around named partners J. Lansing Kimmey and J. Craig Murphy. That length of practice, in itself, does not tell you whether the firm is any good. What it does establish is that Kimmey & Murphy, P.C. has been generating enough client work to remain solvent across three decades, which rules out a certain category of concern outright. Longevity in a competitive legal market like Atlanta requires a steady referral base; that base does not accumulate without some minimum level of client satisfaction over time.

The practice areas are extensive for two attorneys: criminal defense, DUI at multiple court levels, traffic offenses, personal injury (weighted toward auto collisions), workers' compensation, divorce, child custody, probate, estate planning, and civil litigation. Kimmey & Murphy, P.C. positions the breadth as a feature rather than a compromise: a family dealing with a DUI arrest and a divorce can keep both files in the same building. Whether two partners can genuinely sustain quality across that range is a different question, and one worth asking directly during an intake call. Some of those practice areas, such as estate planning and probate, overlap in client base and procedure enough that managing them under one roof is sensible. Others, like criminal defense and workers' compensation, pull in different directions in terms of litigation style. The 30-plus years says the client flow has been there; it does not settle the depth question on any single specialty.

The website for Kimmey & Murphy, P.C. is organized sensibly around Home, Attorneys, Practice Areas, Client Resources, Contact, and Blog. The Client Resources section is a meaningful addition; small firms frequently omit it. Each practice area gets its own section, so someone researching Georgia workers' compensation does not have to comb through a general overview to find it. A maintained blog indicates the site has been updated over time rather than published once and frozen. The attorney bios name both partners and give enough professional background to distinguish each one's focus, which helps a prospective client decide who to ask for when calling.

The physical footprint backs up the geography claimed. Kimmey & Murphy, P.C. lists an Atlanta address on Peachtree Street alongside a second office in Dawsonville. Dawsonville sits roughly 50 miles from Atlanta near the North Georgia mountains, squarely inside the rural counties the firm names as part of its service area. Carrying the overhead of a second office that far out is some evidence that the Northern Georgia coverage is operational. For anyone in Dawson County or the neighboring counties, that address alone changes whether Kimmey & Murphy, P.C. is a practical option worth pursuing over a drive to Atlanta.

The firm states that clients reach the named attorneys directly, not a call-routing layer. At a two-person practice, that claim is structurally more plausible than at a large firm where the same promise could mean almost anything. Phone access is listed as 24/7 alongside standard office hours of Monday through Friday, nine to five. In criminal defense and DUI work, after-hours availability is not incidental: arrests happen at midnight and on weekends. Anyone contacting Kimmey & Murphy, P.C. on a criminal matter should confirm the 24/7 reach during a first call, since the listed policy and the actual response time are not always the same thing. It is also worth asking whether weekend calls roll to a voicemail or to a live attorney.

On the rating side, Kimmey & Murphy, P.C. carries 28 or more reviews on Trustindex at a 4.2-star average, plus a four-star-or-higher rating on Martindale drawn from at least three peer reviews by other attorneys. Peer ratings on Martindale are harder to accumulate than client star counts because they require professional recognition from practitioners who have worked against or alongside the firm. Reviews also appear on Yelp and Bippermedia with 15 listed there, and the firm holds an active profile on Lawyers.com. The BBB profile exists but shows as "Not Rated" with no accreditation listed. BBB accreditation requires active fee-paid enrollment, which many credible practices never pursue; the entry is neutral, not negative. The spread across multiple platforms does suggest the firm has been doing business long enough for review records to accumulate organically across different review audiences.

Taken together, Kimmey & Murphy, P.C. presents a long-running two-partner firm with two functioning offices, a multi-platform review presence, peer ratings on Martindale, and a claimed named-attorney direct-contact policy. The case for choosing this firm rests on the Northern Georgia footprint and the cross-practice convenience for families with overlapping legal needs. What the listing cannot resolve is whether two attorneys can hold expertise depth across nine or ten practice areas, or whether some of those listed specialties receive only occasional attention. That answer lives in the intake conversation, not the website.

---