All-Star Trading Pins

Built around one narrow obsession, All-Star Trading Pins makes custom enamel pins for teams and leagues across the US and Canada, run out of Portland, Oregon. No promotional products catalog, no lanyards, no key chains. Just pins, mostly for sports, and that focus shows up in the level of specification All-Star Trading Pins puts on the page.

Soft enamel and hybrid pin lines

Two product lines do the work. The Soft Enamel Pins are the traditional route, and the Hybrid Trading Pins are the upgrade, supporting unlimited colors and gradients for designs that a flat enamel fill cannot hold. The technical detail goes further than other pin sellers bother with: up to seven enamel colors, a minimum metal thickness of 1.5mm, and dual clutches on any pin 1.5 inches or larger so the heavier ones do not flop or fall off a jersey. That last point is the sort of thing only someone who has handled a lot of these would think to mention, and it reads like a detail drawn from experience instead of a marketing brief.

Sports and leagues served

The sports coverage reads like a list assembled from real orders. Baseball and softball lead, with Cooperstown tournament pins called out by name. Cooperstown is practically the spiritual home of youth baseball pin trading, and naming it specifically places All-Star Trading Pins squarely inside that culture rather than hovering at its edge. Beyond that the company handles hockey, soccer, volleyball, football, ice skating, roller derby, curling, cheerleading, and umpire pins. Curling and roller derby are not categories a generic vendor would invent. The company has clearly filled those orders and decided to advertise the capability, and that kind of specificity is the most persuasive thing on the All-Star Trading Pins site.

Ordering process and pricing

How the order runs is laid out as a five-step sequence: get a quote, work through design, approve the proof, manufacture, and ship. Turnaround is stated at two to three weeks, a realistic window for custom metal work rather than an implausible overnight promise. Pricing is quote-based, US shipping is free, and All-Star Trading Pins says there are no taxes or hidden fees. There is also a competitor price-match policy, which tells you the pin market is competitive enough that they expect buyers to be shopping around.

Checking independent reviews

Here is where things get less tidy. Independent reviews are scarce. A Chamber of Commerce listing shows a 2.0-star rating, but it rests on a single reviewer, which is far too small a sample to mean much in either direction. One unhappy or one careless rater moves a number like that completely, so it registers as the absence of a reputation more than the presence of a bad one. No Google, Trustpilot, or Yelp ratings for the Portland incarnation of All-Star Trading Pins came up in a search.

Confusing Florida namesake

Complicating things further, a BBB profile exists for a similarly named business, "All Star Trading Pins," but it is registered at a Kissimmee, Florida address with a different phone number and is marked Not Rated. That looks like a separate entity entirely, not the Oregon company. Anyone trying to vet All-Star Trading Pins should be careful not to conflate the two, because the name overlap is close enough to mislead someone doing due diligence.

Social media presence

On social media the company has a Facebook page under the handle allstartradingpins and a confirmed TikTok account. Those channels show activity and a public face, though they are not the same as accumulated independent reviews. The honest summary: the work product is described in convincing detail, while the third-party verdict on it is mostly still unwritten.

Reaching the company directly

All-Star Trading Pins does well on being reachable. A phone number is displayed prominently on the homepage along with support hours of 9am to 6pm CST, and the Portland location is stated openly. A quote and contact form is the main way to start an order, which fits a company whose entire model is custom work priced per job. For a buyer who wants to talk to a person before placing a few hundred custom pins, getting someone on the line looks straightforward.

Claimed industry experience

The experience claim on the All-Star Trading Pins site is the usual sort of marketing line: sixty-plus combined years across the team in pin design and manufacturing. It is unverifiable from the outside, and combined-years figures always flatter, but it is at least consistent with how detailed the product specs are. A team unfamiliar with the craft would not be specifying clutch counts and minimum metal gauge.

Weighing the overall verdict

My verdict lands in lukewarm territory, and the reason is the gap between presentation and proof. The All-Star Trading Pins site does a strong job describing what the company builds and how, and contact is easy, so the friction of getting started is low. What is missing is a body of independent customer feedback to confirm the experience matches the pitch, and the lone 2.0-star data point plus the confusing Florida namesake do not help. For a low-stakes order, All-Star Trading Pins is a fine place to get a quote and judge the design conversation for yourself.

For a large or time-sensitive run, asking for references or sample pins before paying would be the sensible move. The capability is plausible given the depth of the product detail. The track record is just not yet on public display, and that is the one thing a careful buyer needs to factor in.