Someone arrested in New Orleans or Jefferson Parish at two in the morning needs a real phone number that gets answered and a lawyer whose practice is narrow enough that the person on the other end has seen the charge before. The Law Office Of Robert S. Toale puts both of those up front: a (504) line flagged for round-the-clock calls, and a practice that takes criminal cases only. No divorce, no real estate, no will drafting tacked on to fill the calendar. That focus is the first thing worth weighing.

Robert Toale is a solo attorney working out of an office in Gretna, just across the river from New Orleans, and the Law Office Of Robert S. Toale handles defense for adults and juveniles, including college students and visitors who got into trouble while in town. The charge list at the Law Office Of Robert S. Toale is long and specific. DWI and DUI. Drug matters running from marijuana possession up through distribution and trafficking. Violent crimes including assault, battery, and homicide. Sexual offenses, white-collar cases such as embezzlement, fraud, and wire fraud, federal charges, weapon offenses, probation violations, and expungements for people trying to clear an old record. A visitor to the site can see at a glance whether their situation falls inside what this office does, which is more useful than a vague promise to help with whatever walks through the door.

Three decades on one side of the courtroom

The biography section is where the credibility gets concrete. Robert Toale has been defending criminal cases for more than thirty years, took his undergraduate degree at Tulane and his law degree at Loyola University New Orleans, and has stayed inside criminal defense the whole time. A resume that shows depth in one lane rather than a little of everything tends to be more reassuring for someone facing a serious charge, and this one reads that way.

He has also held the presidency of the Louisiana Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. In December 2018 that same group gave him its Albert Tate Jr. Award, described as its highest honor. Peer leadership of a statewide defense bar is not something a marketing budget buys; colleagues vote on it. On top of that, Louisiana has certified Toale as Capital Lead Trial Counsel, the qualification required to be lead attorney in death-penalty cases. For most clients facing far lesser charges, that certification points to the depth of the courtroom work the Law Office Of Robert S. Toale has accumulated.

Selection to Super Lawyers has come every year from 2015 through 2026, an unbroken run of peer recognition. It is a designation lawyers earn through nomination and review by other lawyers, not a customer star count, so it carries a different kind of weight than a rating left by a client. Stacked next to the Tate award and the bar presidency, the pattern is consistent: people who practice criminal law in Louisiana hold the Law Office Of Robert S. Toale in high regard.

What the ratings show and where they go quiet

On the public review side, the picture is solid but a little uneven. The Law Office Of Robert S. Toale carries a perfect 10 out of 10 on Avvo, the lawyer-rating platform, though the search did not surface how many ratings feed that score, so a careful reader should treat the number as strong without knowing its sample size. Martindale lists at least six reviews with a score noted at 4.2 or higher. There is also a Yelp listing, but neither its rating nor its review count came through clearly, so it sits as a presence rather than a measurable verdict. None of that contradicts the peer honors; it rounds them out with client-facing feedback that, where visible, runs favorable.

The Law Office Of Robert S. Toale also keeps a testimonials page of its own, which is self-selected by nature and useful as color but secondary to the third-party scores. Taken together, the outside profile points in the same direction as the credentials: a practice that the people who know this area of law take seriously, with a modest but favorable public footprint.

The phone number sits where you would look for it, hours run Monday through Friday from 8:30 in the morning to 5:30 in the evening, and the Gretna street address is listed plainly, with after-hours calls noted as covered. For someone making a frightened first call after an arrest, knowing the line is staffed outside business hours matters. The contact side of the Law Office Of Robert S. Toale listing does its job without making a visitor hunt.

If there is anything to flag, it is the natural ceiling of a solo practice. One attorney, however experienced, has finite hours, and a person with a complex federal case or a capital matter should ask directly how the workload gets handled and who else, if anyone, touches the file. That is a fair question for any small firm. The depth of Toale's trial credentials gives reasonable confidence the answer would hold up under questioning, but the question is still worth asking. The expungement work, by contrast, suits a solo office well, since it rewards a lawyer who knows the local clerks and procedures by heart.

The Law Office Of Robert S. Toale offers a single-focus criminal practice, three decades of trial work, a statewide defense bar that awarded its top honor to this office, capital-counsel certification, an unbroken Super Lawyers streak, and a phone that answers around the clock. The credentials behind the Law Office Of Robert S. Toale are verifiable and the contact path is clear. What the listing cannot settle is how the Law Office Of Robert S. Toale handles a specific charge at a specific stage of a specific case. That answer comes from picking up the phone, and the evidence here is enough to make that call worth placing.

---