Haggerty Hinton & Cosgrove LLP

Where do you turn after a workplace injury or a car wreck in the Scranton area, when you want a lawyer who has been doing this since long before most of the competition opened its doors? That is the practical question this listing answers. Haggerty Hinton & Cosgrove LLP is a general civil firm in Dunmore, Pennsylvania, founded in 1965, and it puts its longevity front and center, claiming attorneys with more than 90 years of combined experience in personal injury work alone. For someone in Northeastern Pennsylvania weighing whether to call a local outfit or a regional billboard firm, that history is a real data point worth taking seriously.

Practice areas for injury and transactional work

The practice areas are broad in the way a town firm tends to be broad. Personal injury covers the usual range: auto accidents, defective products, medical malpractice, and slip-and-fall claims. Workers' compensation gets specific attention, with workplace injuries, back and neck injuries, and repetitive trauma all named. Beyond the injury side, Haggerty Hinton & Cosgrove LLP handles Social Security Disability, estate planning and probate (wills and trusts), commercial litigation, business transactions, real estate transactions, and bond representation. The client list described runs from individuals to businesses and on to financial and educational institutions, which is a wider spread than a pure plaintiff-side injury shop usually claims.

Breadth across personal injury and business services

That breadth is worth pausing on. A firm that drafts your will, closes your house, and also sues a hospital for malpractice is offering one relationship across the messy stuff of a life, and for a lot of people that single point of contact is genuinely convenient. The flip side is that breadth can read as thinness, a sign that nobody inside specializes deeply. The brief does not settle that tension, and honestly I went back and forth on it while reading the offerings. The 1965 founding date and the heavy emphasis on injury and compensation suggest those are the bread-and-butter areas, with the transactional work serving the existing client base.

Professional recognition from peers

The credentials are where Haggerty Hinton & Cosgrove LLP stops talking about itself and lets third parties weigh in, and that shift is meaningful. Attorney J. Timothy Hinton Jr. has been named a Pennsylvania Super Lawyers honoree for sixteen consecutive years. Super Lawyers limits that designation to roughly the top five percent of attorneys in the state, drawn from peer nominations across a pool of more than 34,000 lawyers. Sixteen years running is a sustained peer judgment, confirmed by the Super Lawyers profile, and it is the clearest external credential Haggerty Hinton & Cosgrove LLP can point to.

Martindale-Hubbell ratings for legal ability

On top of that, every attorney at Haggerty Hinton & Cosgrove LLP holds a BV Distinguished rating through Martindale-Hubbell. That rating comes from peer review, measuring how other lawyers and judges score legal ability and ethical standards. It is not a count of happy clients, and it should not be read as one. What it tells you is that within the professional community, these attorneys are regarded as competent and ethical by the people who watch them work cases. For a firm leaning on a six-decade track record, peer ratings are the kind of evidence that is harder to spin than a testimonial page.

Haggerty Hinton & Cosgrove LLP also makes a point about direct attorney access, saying clients deal with their lawyer throughout the matter rather than getting handed off to staff. That is a common pitch and easy to promise, so treat it as a stated intention more than a verified fact. Still, it is consistent with the picture of a smaller, established practice where the named partners actually carry the files.

Client feedback largely absent online

Client-side reputation is another matter. A Yelp listing exists for Haggerty Hinton & Cosgrove LLP in Scranton but carries no posted user reviews or ratings at all. The Facebook page shows 238 likes and 14 check-ins, with no visible review tally. A ReachAttorneys profile references positive client feedback about fair pricing and prompt responses, but attaches no number or star rating to it. No Google, Trustpilot, or BBB review counts surfaced in a search. So the professional standing is well documented while the lay-client voice is close to silent online.

Getting in touch with Haggerty Hinton & Cosgrove LLP is straightforward. The main page carries a street address in Dunmore, a phone number, and a fax line, and a contact page is also available. Nothing is buried behind a form wall, and for a prospective client who would rather pick up the phone than fill out a web form, that openness is a genuine advantage.

So how should a reader weigh all this? The case for Haggerty Hinton & Cosgrove LLP rests on durability and peer respect: a 1965 founding, a partner with sixteen straight years of Super Lawyers recognition, firm-wide BV Distinguished ratings, and a deep bench of experience in the injury and compensation work most people will actually call about. The website does its basic job, presenting practice areas clearly and making contact easy.

What keeps nagging is the missing client chorus. Peer ratings tell you the legal community trusts these lawyers, and that is valuable, but it is a different thing from knowing how it felt to be a client whose disability claim dragged on, or whose injury case settled for less than hoped.

A firm this established should, by now, have a visible trail of people willing to say what the experience was like. The near-total absence of posted client reviews across Yelp, Google, and the rest leaves a quiet space exactly where a worried first-time caller would most want reassurance. The professional credentials at Haggerty Hinton & Cosgrove LLP are strong enough that the gap is unlikely to mean trouble. It is just unproven territory, and Haggerty Hinton & Cosgrove LLP cannot point you to the one thing that would close it.